- AutorIn
- Bartholomeus Nes van Hulzen
- Titel
- Solidarity Between Sacred and Profane
- Zitierfähige Url:
- https://nbn-resolving.org/urn:nbn:de:bsz:15-qucosa2-941456
- Datum der Einreichung
- 17.08.2023
- Datum der Verteidigung
- 28.05.2024
- Abstract (EN)
- In his dissertation, Van Hulzen argues that solidarity should, first and foremost, be understood as a question of how social cohesion, in one form or another, is possible under the conditions of modernity. Theories of solidarity often try to answer this question by either arguing for solidarity based on what people share in common, or for solidarity that relies on what distinguishes them from one another. Contrary to these positions, Van Hulzen argues that the distinction between both types of solidarity is tied to the dualistic nature of liberal individualism, and that the ideal of solidarity originally developed as an ideal aimed at overcoming this problematic aspect of liberal individualism. This argument is developed through a close reading and contextualization of the work of Emile Durkheim, which plays a central role in the evolution of the ideal of solidarity. Through an original interpretation of Durkheim’s work, van Hulzen demonstrates that Durkheim’s theory of solidarity, contrary to common claims, already moves beyond the dichotomy present in many contemporary debates on solidarity. However, in a critique of Durkheim’s understanding of the relationship between solidarity and individualism, the ideal of solidarity is pursued beyond Durkheim’s theoretical framework in the second half of the dissertation. A deeper analysis of the problem, and a first step toward understanding solidarity as a process of social transformation, is offered through a new interpretation of Marcel Mauss’s theory of gift exchange. These insights are further explored in the final chapter, which considers various theories of play as models for a concept of transformative solidarity.
- Freie Schlagwörter (EN)
- Solidarity, Individualism, Gift, Play, Durkheim
- Klassifikation (DDC)
- 300
- Den akademischen Grad verleihende / prüfende Institution
- Universität Leipzig, Leipzig
- Version / Begutachtungsstatus
- angenommene Version / Postprint / Autorenversion
- URN Qucosa
- urn:nbn:de:bsz:15-qucosa2-941456
- Veröffentlichungsdatum Qucosa
- 18.10.2024
- Dokumenttyp
- Dissertation
- Sprache des Dokumentes
- Englisch
- Lizenz / Rechtehinweis
CC BY-NC-ND 4.0- Inhaltsverzeichnis
Introduction 1 I. Solidarity as the Question of Modernity 17 1. Solidarity and Political Economy in Early Nineteenth Century France 19 2. Solidarity and Civil Religion in Early Nineteenth Century France 26 3. Durkheim on Mechanical Solidarity 36 4. The Ideal of Organic Solidarity Reconsidered 43 5. Mechanical or Organic Solidarity? 52 6. Organic Solidarity in the Theories of Rahel Jaeggi and Axel Honneth 61 Conclusion 71 II. The Cult of the Individual 74 1. The Dreyfus Affair 76 2. The Origins of Excessive Individualism 82 3. The Sacred-Profane Distinction Reconsidered 95 4. The Cult of the Individual 107 5. The Sacred Rights of Man 114 6. Marx on the Jewish Question 126 Conclusion 134 III. Gift Exchange Beyond Sacred and Profane 138 1. Mauss on Bolshevism 140 2. The Noncontractual Element in Exchange 145 3. The Gift in Durkheim’s Shadow 149 4. The Force in the Thing 158 5. Mana 161 6. Layers of Exchange 167 7. The End of the Spirit of the Gift 177 8. Mana and the Sacred 185 9. Sacrifice and the Separation of Sacred and Profane 188 10. From Sacrifice to the Ideology of the Pure Gift 195 Conclusion 201 IV. The Transformative Power of Play 205 1. Play as Schiller’s Answer to the Question of Modernity 206 2. Gadamer on Transformation Through Play 216 3. Huizinga on Play as Sacralization 225 4. Agamben on Play as Profanation 237 Conclusion 246 Conclusion 251 Bibliography 262